• Raided Score: 75
• Publication: The Whiskey Wash
• Excerpt: Those richer, deeper flavors work remarkably well with its still-light mouthfeel. Enjoyable neat, its accrued flavors of would nicely lend it to an Irish coffee or an emerald. Overall, a happy marriage between whiskey and stout.
• Read Full Review

• Raided Score: 86
• Publication: The Whiskey Jug
• Excerpt: Jameson Caskmates Stout Finish is a fun and interesting whisky that’s multifaceted and tasty. Not your everyday Irish.
• Read Full Review

• Raided Score: 81
• Publication: Whisky Advocate
• Excerpt: Perplexingly experimental in results. A whiskey for stout drinkers? A stout for whiskey drinkers? Incomparable to other Jameson. Funny peculiar.
• Read Full Review

• Raided Score: 84
• Publication: Distiller
• Excerpt: The mouthfeel is significantly richer and heavier than the base spirit, but the finish is brief and somewhat dry and lighter than expected with a slight note of black pepper. This whiskey is an exciting, confusing, and fun experiment.
• Read Full Review

• Raided Score: 91
• Publication: WhiskyCast
• Excerpt: The taste still has the usual Jameson pepperiness balanced by notes of oak, dark chocolate, caramel, honey, and just a tiny bit of happiness. The finish is very long with a tiny bit of oakiness, dark chocolate, cocoa, coffee beans, and touches of vanilla and honey.
• Read Full Review

• Raided Score: 88
• Publication: Drinkhacker
• Excerpt: Standard Jameson: simple and sweet, with a mix of fruit and nuts and a backing of gentle grains. I don’t get a distinctly stout character in Caskmates — maybe a touch of hops on the finish — but on its own merits it’s a whiskey worth picking up, particularly if you’re an Irish fan.
• Read Full Review

• Raided Score: 91
• Publication: Wine Enthusiast
• Excerpt: The flavor evokes a pleasing combination of beer and whiskey, accented with hops, bitter chocolate and a clove-spiced finish. It even feels slightly fizzy, like the carbonation of beer.
• Read Full Review

Raided Score is a conversion from an external site's score, to our in house uniform scoring system. Please see the FAQ for more.