Excerpt: The finish finally evokes some caramel corn notes, but these are gentle and integrate well into the spirit as a whole. Old and new come together awfully well here, it turns out. Gifted horse indeed.
Excerpt: I hate to say it, but it’s possible that the bottling at 115 proof was a mistake, as at closer to 90-95 proof, this drinks pretty well. That’s not to say it’s not oaky. It’s still an oak bomb, but not overly so.
Excerpt: The palate follows through with bold fruitcake-like flavor, lots of molasses, caramel, orange peel and clove, finishing long. But the proof is so high, even with plenty of dilution it's still quite fiery and challenging to sip.
Raided Score is a conversion from an external site's score, to our in house uniform scoring system. Please see the FAQ for more.
Less oak but more caramel. More ethanol and younger grain notes but overall not offensive. Maltier and sweeter, little more molasses, caramel and butterscotch driven.
Thin and woody caramel. Mouthfeel and taste alone, I would peg this as a 45% ABV dram and not a 57.5. Dangerously easy drinking. Mild astringency, clove and a good deal more caramel and butterscotch.
Medium but shorter than Rhetoric. Mildly astringent and way sweeter but not bad at all.
I've heard a lot about Gifted Horse but not a lot involving Gifted Horse. Aka, I've heard about it but nothing involving how good it is or what's in the bottle. It's good but to me, other than the mellow mouthfeel and high ABV, there is nothing super notable about this dram. As a result, I give this dram a rating of 5.
Our in house critic rates spirits on a scale of 0-10 (10 best) and is aggregated the same as external sources